Building Better Businesses by Tearing Them Down First

October 24th, 2009

tearing down

(image from Shutterstock)

When you really start to think about social media and start to listen in to what “consultants” are telling their clients to do you’ll notice a pattern.  The pattern is that most companies are told they need to go on Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, Youtube, and that they need a blog.  Then, they are given a few supplemental “listening” tools or applications that they can use for the various platforms.  In fact, when you really think about it, there’s almost a cookie cutter approach to social media.  I mean how many different platforms can you possibly recommend to your various clients?  I know what you’re thinking, it’s not the tools you use but how you use them; ok fine, but even so, there’s a finite way in which we can use the various tools out there.   I’m willing to bet that if you took 100 of these so called “consultant” folks and asked them to develop a strategy for a client that almost all of them would recommend the same set of tools but with slightly varied degrees of usage.

This is one of the many reasons why I am focusing on social business accountability and ROI because regardless of what tools, platforms, or strategies you pick; at the end of the day; you have to be understand where you money is going and what you are getting out of your investment.  In my opinion the social business and accountability space is really where the meat of the work is.  This is where the strategy comes into play because you are looking at an organization as a whole and trying to infuse it with new technologies to strengthen the brand and make it more money.  The ROI and accountability component is especially challenging and complex (and hence the most interesting) because companies are all using a varying combination of tools to measure and track their customers.  This is where the fun comes into play because you really to understand how the business works and interacts with it’s customers; the foundation of any social media strategy.

In my opinion one of the first steps to any social media strategy has nothing to do with setting up a Facebook fan page, or *gasp* a twitter account.  No, one of the first steps needs to be based entirely around measurement.  This is where the social media ROI diagnostic comes into play.  Remember, that the new technologies we are looking at today are just the beginning, business is never going to b done the same way again.  In an online conversation I had with Olivier Blanchard he said, “we have to tear things down before we can build them back up,” and I couldn’t agree more.  We need to stop making excuses for not being able to measure the ROI from social media campaigns.  I’ve heard plenty of “consultants” say, “well measuring any type of ROI of marketing is hard so why should social media be any different,” or, “you can’t measure the ROI of a television commercial or a billboard at but you’re still investing in those.”  First of all there are measurements that companies are using for any type of marketing they do, just because you don’t know what those measurements are doesn’t mean that they don’t exist.  Second, since when have we decided to run our businesses based off previous decades old schools of thought?  Just because you couldn’t measure something ten years ago doesn’t mean that you can’t measure it today.  Sure, if you want to say that you can’t measure the ROI from a billboard then that’s fine, but why on earth are you applying that same lax approach to measurement to the online space?  Anything that is done online is much more trackable, measurable, and calculable so don’t clump it in with anything that has to do with offline measurement.

Let the tearing down begin.

The Importance of a Social Media ROI Diagnostic

October 22nd, 2009

stethoscope diagnostic

I’m going to be going much more in depth with social media ROI in the coming months so I’m hoping you stick around with me.  My company Chess Media Group (I’m told the site goes live Monday!) has been working on some very exciting things in the ROI space that we will be announcing and showcasing over the course of the next few months.  First off, I should preface this by saying that Chess Media Group is a social business consultancy and not a social media consultancy. This means we look at how social media impacts business; we don’t just see social media as another “media” channel.  Now having said that let me also state that the key to any successful social media strategy (and subsequently a campaign) is going to start with building and setting up an ROI framework.  Forget about launching three month campaigns all the time and just relax for a minute.  I’m not saying you shouldn’t have a social media presence to respond to issues that arise online.  I’m saying don’t spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on a campaign without an ROI framework, it’s pointless.  Again, start from setting up your ROI framework.

I can definitely go into this in more depth and I will over the next few months, but let’s start off with some of the things that a social media ROI diagnostic should accomplish.  A social media ROI diagnostic should give you the following:

  • A solid understanding of how the business operates, makes money, and interacts with customers.
  • A solid definition and understanding of what exactly ROI is and what impact is, ROI = financial; Impact = non-financial
  • Insight into how existing analytics platforms work within the site, what do they calculate; what can/can’t they do?
  • What are the company business objectives for all of the social media efforts and what are their respective metrics and benchmarks?  This should be broken down by business function or department.  See Metrics Man for a good example of what I mean.
  • Analysis of a customer database or CRM system and what their capabilities are and how they can be integrated with other solutions.
  • Analysis of any overlap between social media ROI and traditional marketing ROI, the goal here it to improve and maximize both.
  • Idea of what the quick ROI wins are (low hanging fruit anyone?) and what the longer term approaches are.
  • Resource analysis in terms of who (most likely a team) is going to be managing the social media efforts and how they are going to be managed
  • A breakdown of business challenges and opportunities that are keeping the company from calculating ROI (can be complex, we will explore this in detail later).
  • A breakdown of the technology challenges and opportunities that are keeping the company from calculating ROI (also can be very complex and something we will cover later).
  • Increased marketing credibility and authority within the company

All of the above topics can be expanded upon; however, this should give you an idea of the types of things you want to accomplish from a social media ROI diagnostic.  I firmly believe that setting up a solid social media ROI framework will not only allow you to understand, measure, and maximize social media ROI but also allow you to improve your marketing ROI and accountability as a whole.  This type of framework focuses on enterprise size clients with large budgets.  As you can see understanding and getting to ROI is not a trivial task, especially for a global company. The good news is that once you run your initial ROI diagnostic you won’t have to do it again for quite a while, if ever with the exception of continuous monitoring and adapting.

The reality is that moving forward companies (enterprise companies especially) are absolutely going to need a more accountable way of measuring their social media efforts, it might not happen tomorrow or next month; but you better believe that with companies like Chess Media Group offering ROI and accountability services that this is going to become a standard and an absolute must for measuring social media efforts.  One-off solutions or simple analysis of Google analytics aren’t going to cut it guys; we’re talking about full-scale solutions here; solutions that are going to be at the foundation of all of your social media efforts.

It’s time to get real about Social Media ROI; no more bullshit.

Enterprise Social Media Management

October 18th, 2009

(yes, that is the enterprise from star trek…get it?) Update: edited to remove company names to avoid any misunderstanding I’m sitting at the Vegas airport after having donated by money to the Vegas charity foundation (aka the casinos) and was just thinking about some of the interesting conversations I had with folks during the course [...]

You Have Social Media ROI, Now What?

October 16th, 2009

(image from Shutterstock) The conversations around social media ROI are getting more and more attention; which is great.  I’m hoping this will be one of the top issues on everyone’s social media agenda for 2010 and beyond; I’m also hoping that all of these people are going to come to me as clients…but that’s another [...]

What it Takes to Get Somewhere

October 14th, 2009

I go to the gym everyday (yes that’s right) but when I go I have a few options to get there.  I can walk, take a bus, flag down a cab, take a zip car, etc.  I always choose walking (around a mile) because that’s what works for me.  If I want to go to [...]

Two Examples of Companies Measuring Social Media ROI

October 12th, 2009

I wanted to share 2 examples of companies that have been able to share a very clear ROI from their social media efforts.  If the two small businesses below can calculate social media ROI so than can your multi-million dollar company.  The examples below aren’t exhaustive and of course there are things that can be [...]