Archive for August, 2009

Social Media is a Unique Business Decision

August 28th, 2009

unique

Think about all of the possible marketing initiatives that a company can undertake.  Everything from billboards to sponsoring events to social media campaigns to television commercials.  What makes social media so unique when compared to the alternatives (ok there might be a few things).

  • Before you purchase a billboard which costs tens of thousands of dollars (for a short period of time) you have to research the best location to place it and then pay someone to actually put it up.
  • Before you purchase a full page spread in the NY Times which costs multiple tens of thousands (or more) of dollars you need to have an entire creative team put together the content and get it published.
  • Before you sponsor an event that will also cost tens of thousands of dollars (depending on the event) you have to research the best event to sponsor, decide on how you want to sponsor the event, etc.
  • Do I even need to mention television commercials that costs 6 figures+ just to get them aired (think of creative/production/research costs)

Traditionally, with any type of marketing  that you do that there is usually a pretty hefty cost assigned to researching, developing, launching, and then creating a campaign or a strategy.  You can’t just test something out without spending a lot of money and traditional marketing campaigns cost well into the six figures (oftentimes more) when you take into account the process from A to Z.  So to summarize, everything (or mostly everything) in the traditional marketing space has a large cost assigned to it.

I’m hoping you can see where social media is different.  What’s the cost of creating a Google Alert or using one of the many free monitoring tools out there to listen to your consumers?  What’s the cost of just going out and creating a twitter account or a facebook fan page?

I’m not going to say that the cost is free, but it’s not too far from it.  Now keep in mind I’m basically talking about the cost for any company to play around with social media aka have an employee in their spare time test out the waters; this won’t cost much.  Someone with an understanding of the social media tools out there that works for a company can easily handle this.  Find a passionate employee at a company and let him have at it.

So what?

Well this means a few things for businesses:

  • The cost to play around with social technologies on the web today is minimal which means that this is an attractive “test” environment for companies to engage in.
  • The majority of the social media cost doesn’t go into an actual product or physical deliverable like it to does with traditional media.  The cost goes into intellectual capital i.e. developing a strategy, figuring out a process, working to change the corporate culture within the company, etc (and yes hiring employees if needed).  Most of the physical tools on the web such as twitter and facebook are in themselves free to use.
  • The fact that social media is a low-cost test environment means that companies may succeed (whatever success is) without spending a lot of time/money but it also means that there is a high chance for companies to fail or to not see their expectations met.  Again, this is because testing doesn’t mean investing, meaning that a lot of the strategic and research components will not be funded…yet.
  • The cost to research and build a strategy is less than the cost of actually engaging in social media; several companies might see engagement as a more cost effective approach.  After all, why spend money figuring out what and how you should be doing something when you can just do it and find out?

This post is really just meant to get you to think about why social media is such a unique business decision.  Most people view social media as something that falls under marketing yet social media has very different characteristics that are associated with traditional marketing.

Have anything you want to add?  Any ideas/thoughts on this?

Why Social Media Makes Absolutely No Business Sense

August 26th, 2009

no-sense

(don’t ask about the picture, just admit it’s awesome!)

I know what you’re thinking, “Hey doesn’t this idiot run a social media consultancy?”  Yes I do, I’m playing devil’s advocate here so play along!

Pretend you’re a social media consultant and I’m the CMO of a large company (or even a small one).  I’m interested in the social media space and have had you come in to chat with me about what can be done.  I’m interested but also very skeptical as to the value of social media from a business standpoint.  Why am I skeptical and why am I having so much trouble seeing the business value from social media?  Glad you asked!

  • Why would I want to invest my money into social media when you can’t even identify what the ROI is from my investment?   I have several marketing programs going on that I’m investing in.  Each one of those programs has a specific dollar amount that is put in and a specific dollar amount that is generated aka ROI.  In order to invest in social media I’m going to have to take money out of some of the programs that have already shown me a clear ROI and put it into something that you apparently can’t calculate the ROI from.  Why do I want to do this?
  • My company is already making money and has been profitable for the past 10 years without ever using social media, why should I start now?
  • The average lifespan of a CMO is 2 years, by the time we build and internal social media structure, benchmark/create metrics, research, and then execute; I won’t be here anymore.  Why do I want to approve a budget for something that I won’t be around for?
  • Social media is really just a guessing game.  Things are changing so quickly in the space that it’s impossible to know what’s going to work and what isn’t.  I can’t take the risk of investing in something that has the potential to blow up in my face.  It’s just not reliable.
  • We can’t measure any real bottom line value from conversations that are taking place online.  So what if the social media efforts are driving more eyeballs, clicks, or conversations.  I need to invest in something that can actually make me money.
  • The tools, metrics, and methods in the social media space are not consistent.  I hear consultants talking about all sorts of things like “risk of ignoring” or the “social influence index,” what the hell does that mean?  The industry can’t even agree with itself and I’m supposed to get involved?  Maybe I’ll wait another year or 2.
  • We’re a large international company and more of our audience probably exists offline then online, why should I be spending my money on online activities?

So Mr. social media consultant, convince me.  Why should I be investing in social media?  Can you answer any or all of the above questions?  Have any other questions you want to add?

The Social Media Motivational Speakers and the Consultants/Strategists

August 24th, 2009

I think there are two types of social media professionals today: the social media motivational speakers and the social media strategists (or consultants).  We need both, but they serve very different roles within the social media space and within organizations.
The social media motivational speaker:
I won’t list out any names here because I don’t want anyone [...]

Did You Know? The Social Media Edition

August 23rd, 2009

You guys all remember this video right?

I recently found this video, just like the one above with the same music, but geared much more towards social media.

What did you think of the vid?

The PR Agency of Satan, Brody PR

August 19th, 2009

This morning I woke up to find 35+ emails from Brody PR, a company that is apparently trying to help promote someone’s book.  I don’t know whose book they are promoting and quite frankly I don’t really care at this point.  The PR firm sent out emails to a long list of people that included:

Shel [...]